Dear Hindutva Right – Please Start Your Own Media Channel

Media bashing is one of the favorite pastimes of the Hindu right. You know those Facebook posts with split images showing supposedly equivalent stories – and how the media reports on one and not the other? The comments section of a story in the Times of India, Deccan Herald, NDTV, Hindu, or whatever are filled with outraged words like “presstitute” and “sikular”.

The media is such an easy target isn’t it? It’s not humanly possible to cover everything and being a business, they’re only going to print the news that they feel people are interested in. Despite what you might think, they have no moral duty to do squat. They’re not some charitable organization whose duty is to provide you with unbiased facts and figures in a column. Stories are written by people who have opinions and we like it that way. We like the media to put a spin on things. Is anyone here interested in a dry recitation of facts? Not me.

If you don’t like what a particular media channel puts out, if you don’t agree with their opinions, if you feel they’re covering up stuff on a regular basis, I have three sweet words for you.

Free. Fucking. Market.

Stop bitching and whining about the “evil media”, get off your butt, and go make some big bucks!

“Waaaah, the TOI is biased and only reports bad things against the BJP!”, or “See how NDTV is not giving enough coverage to the National Herald case because it involves the Gandhi Family!”, or “The Media is going bonkers about Dadri and refusing to cover Prashant Poojary!” or “Why is the Media constantly focusing on the ‘Intolerance’ debate?”.

Well, my dear conspiracy theorists – go watch some other channel then. What’s that? You say no unbiased media exists in the country? Well if you feel there’s sufficient demand, go create your own news channel! Please show us how it’s done. Tell us the truth the way you feel it should be told. Give us what we want, what we really need. Open our eyes. Show us.

But you won’t will you?

And don’t tell me that starting a newspaper is prohibitively expensive. Sure it’s not dirt cheap, but it’s nowhere as expensive as running a hotel, manufacturing cars, or any of the other free markets in India that have plenty of competition. If the target market is as high as you think it is, get a financial backer, demonstrate the demand and take off!

Hindutva types like to make it sound as if the entire country is clamoring for the truth and the desperate media is trying to cover it up. They like to point out the buzz on social networks, trying to show that the entire country is up in arms against the media channels. But guess what? The media is not a monolithic entity like the government that can change only once every 5 years. There’s so much demand for an unbiased media right? Go create your own.

The US has done exactly that. The right wing in America felt that the evil “liberal” media was not representing their point of view. And hello Fox news! What’s more, it’s profitable – it makes more money than any other news channel. I mean sure everyone makes fun of it, but so what? At least someone saw an opportunity and made use of it. Good for them.

So what’s stopping the Hindutva brigade from doing the same thing in India? Go ahead. Stop bitching and whining about the “evil media”, get off your butt, and go make some big bucks! We’re all waiting with bated breath to see what you come up with. Show us how it’s done. Come on, give us the unbiased new we’ve all been waiting for. With so many supporters and such a terrific demand, you can’t fail can you?

But no – it’s much much easier to simply take easy potshots against existing players than actually going out there and changing the game right? Well guess what – the media doesn’t owe you anything. Take it or leave it. Or go make your own.

What do you think of this post?
  • You're an asshole (6)
  • Agree (5)
  • Don't Agree but Interesting (0)

11 thoughts on “Dear Hindutva Right – Please Start Your Own Media Channel”

  1. Bhagwad,
    What’s wrong in calling them out? Free-speech, right?
    I don’t like FlipKart, I say they’re bad. I don’t start a new e-commerce website. I trade with them, but I expect them to be good. I try alternatives. If none exist, I can complain atleast. Do I have to start businesses for everything that I don’t like ?

    “No to abuse, but Yes to complaining”.

    Second, media gets a lot of benefits from state (our money) for doing their job. So, holding them to their task is needed.
    SM is like short-selling. It keeps market/MSM in check.

    I would say, if a media channel doesn’t like so much criticism, they should leave. Not the other way round.

    Reply

    • In reply to Murali

      Absolutely – there is free speech to complain. No one (least of all myself) is suggesting that it’s illegal to complain endlessly.

      I’m just saying that it’s illogical to keep complaining about a service, call it the absolute worst, say that they’ve let the whole country down etc etc., and still not have competing services come up. If not you personally, then at least someone would have seen the business opportunity by now and come up with their own successful right wing media channel. But that hasn’t happened.

      As for government benefits. Not really sure about that. Years ago, I tried running my own newspaper unsuccessfully for 2 years in MP. I don’t remember getting any aid from the government. The most “aid” one can receive would be DAVP government ads. But that’s an exchange of service, not a benefit. And it wasn’t much either – not even enough to keep the newspaper afloat.

      Reply

  2. Okay so media bashing gets your goat. No problems. India bashing gets mine. So, I have a solution for people like you who can’t stand our backward and regressive country.

    Dear lefties,
    please start your own country free of superstition, discrimination, exploitation and bigotry. Stop making India bashing your occupation. Sorry, this superstitious, casteist, backward, regressive, intolerant land is irredeemable.

    Oh wait…you did start that country. Sorry it imploded in 1991 after massacring a few hundred million people.

    Reply

  3. Dear Bhagwad,
    You can’t take Freedom of Speech and Expression from Hindutva people. Its Democratic Country. Why there is Selective Freedom of Speech & Expression.?
    Freedom of Speech & Expression are only for RICH People.?? NOT for Poor People..??

    Reply

  4. Remember 90% of those Pro-Hindu people are POOR. Not Rich like you do.
    You Live in a A/C Flats, Move in a A/C Car and Travel in Flights. Fine i can Understand that, But that not mean you only have FREEDOM to Speak..!!

    Reply

  5. Dear bhagwad sir,
    One Kind suggestion to you. Please Start your Own country free of hinduism, laws & rules.
    Dont complain, start your own. Best wishes and good luck.

    Reply

  6. AAP Launched biggest attack on media in 2014 , they even refuse to come to news channel like zee news which are pro BJP , just watch Zee news debates and you will find many from left , congress and SP blames that channel for running Sangh agenda.

    Why to single out then Hindutvs groups

    Reply

  7. Sir,

    Actually they did on the Internet. Kanchan Gupta was running NitiCentral which went defunct on January the 31st, 2016. It was the main propaganda tool for BJP’s electoral victory in 2014. Seeing how badly they fail quite too often compared to The Wire, Scroll, Janta ka Reporter, etc, the right wingers go back to media bashing with no motivation to keep their hold for long. Just like BJP frittered away its 2014 lead completely, the right wingers fritter away pretty much everything they begin. And a news channel is a huge investment. Peddling out Photoshopped lies through a media channel will surely tarnish their name and reduce their TRP. So as a safe measure, they now hide behind I think Zee Network which appears to be quite favorable to the right.

    Thanks.

    Reply

Leave a Comment